FMS EdgeFMS Edge — home

Guide

What is a Supply Discrepancy Report in Foreign Military Sales?

Updated 26 October 2026Checked against the SAMM: 26 October 2026

A is how a purchaser files a complaint with the Department of War about a delivery that falls short of what the agreed. It covers shortages or overages, wrong items, damage before the shipper released the shipment to the carrier, documentation or billing errors and services not performed as agreed. The , with the supply source, resolves it and determines financial responsibility.

Decision tree: which report a Foreign Military Sales delivery problem needs depends on what went wrong, and the Supply Discrepancy Report, the purchaser's own report, then passes a time test and a value test before the Implementing Agency resolves it. WHAT WENT WRONG DECIDES WHICH REPORT fmsedge.com A delivery does not match what the LOA agreed What went wrong: at the shipper, in the item itself, or with the carrier in transit? No evidence of shipment? That is a supply discrepancy too no signed carrier receipt and shipping document at the shipper in the item itself with the carrier Supply discrepancy shortage or overage, wrong item, damage before release to the carrier, documentation or billing error Quality deficiency a defect in new, as-new or repaired materiel, including one a warranty covers Transportation discrepancy lost or damaged by the carrier, after the shipper released the shipment to it How is a Supply Discrepancy Report submitted and resolved?Supply Discrepancy Report the purchaser submits it on Standard Form 364; not for Building Partner Capacity cases What is a Product Quality Deficiency Report (PQDR)?Product Quality Deficiency Report the DoW users' report; a purchaser reports the same defect on an SDR instead What is a Transportation Discrepancy Report in Foreign Military Sales?Transportation Discrepancy Report on DTS legs the SCO submits DD Form 361; the purchaser cannot submit one Who claims when a Foreign Military Sales shipment is lost or damaged?Own or forwarder-arranged carrier: the purchaser claims directly. Who claims, and where money goes what happens to an SDR Within 12 months of delivery or passage of title, whichever comes first (services: end of performance) Worth $200 or more item plus transportation and handling; misdirected or unordered: any value The IA resolves it with the DoW or commercial supply source, and determines financial responsibility Approved: corrected replacement, rework, or a refund or credit to the purchaser's account Later: disallowed, unless a latent defect justifies it Less: documented, but not reviewed for compensation LOA = Letter of Offer and Acceptance. SDR = Supply Discrepancy Report. DTS = Defense Transportation System. SCO = Security Cooperation Organization. DoW = Department of War. IA = Implementing Agency. A warranty defect goes on an SDR within the warranty's own time limit, even when that is shorter. FMS Edge the report moves on · turned away, or routed elsewhere · correction or credit fmsedge.com · Current as of 11 September 2026 · SAMM C6.4.10 · C6.3.8 · C7.21 · DLM 4000.25

Which report a delivery problem needs depends on what went wrong. A shortage, a wrong item, damage before release to the carrier, a quality defect or a billing error goes on a Supply Discrepancy Report within 12 months of delivery or passage of title. Loss or damage caused by the carrier goes on a Transportation Discrepancy Report, which a U.S. representative files.

Which report, and what happens to it: SDR, TDR, PQDR · Current as of 11 September 2026 · SAMM C6.4.10 · C6.3.8 · C7.21 · DLM 4000.25 · Download PNG

What is a Supply Discrepancy Report?

A is the process an international customer uses to complain to the Department of War about a delivery. It covers product loss, quality deficiencies, damage and other delivery problems.

The Department of War (DoW) has set up a system to quickly validate the problem and respond to the international partner, while documenting trends to preclude recurrence of the discrepancy.

A discrepancy is a difference or variance from a standard. If something does not meet the standard in either quantity or quality, a discrepancy exists. The intention of the U.S. Government () is to resolve the discrepancy and ensure that every effort is made to provide the correct or service in the quantity and quality agreed to in the [SAMM ].

A deviation from a standard can be caused in any number of ways: shipment damage, wrong items, shortages, and many others.

Where the determines that the is responsible, the corrects the discrepancy by a replacement, a refund or credit to the purchaser’s account, or rework of defective items [SAMM , ]. Furthermore, per the standard terms and conditions, Section 5.1, the disclaims any liability for damage or loss to the items incurred after the passage of title, irrespective of whether transportation is by common carrier or by the U.S. [SAMM ]. An exception to this is a discrepancy in billing, which normally occurs after the title has passed to the international partner.

There are three categories of discrepancies. Each has unique reporting requirements for .

  • Supply discrepancies, which capture a wide range of issues
  • Product quality deficiencies, caused by the manufacturer
  • Transportation discrepancies caused by damage or loss during shipment

Supply discrepancies come from shortages or overages, incorrect items, duplicate shipments, improper packing or marking, and condition or quality discrepancies. Those include damage that occurs before the originating shipper releases the shipment to the carrier. They also come from errors in documentation or billing, deficiencies in the performance of services, and cases where the shipper cannot produce evidence of shipment (a signed carrier receipt and a shipping document). For the assumptions of risk the purchaser takes on, the manual points to the Standard Terms and Conditions in Figure C5.F9 [SAMM ].

For shipments processed through freight forwarders, purchasers should direct tracer requests to their freight forwarders before addressing any inquiries to the DoW [SAMM ].

If constructive proof of delivery is provided for an item the purchaser has not received, the purchaser must follow up with its to determine if the item has been received [SAMM ]. When shipments are made through a , an for non-receipt includes documentation from the indicating that no materiel has been received on the applicable requisition and . The denies a non-receipt that does not include this documentation.

An for a shortage can result from a partial shipment of the quantity requested. The supply status received before the shipment, or the shipping document, shows whether the items received are a partial shipment. If an international partner receives a partial shipment, it checks whether the remaining items were received earlier or are still due in to the country.

An is processed only when its estimated value, including transportation and handling costs, is $200 or greater, except for misdirected or unordered shipments. A purchaser may submit an below that value so the problem is documented, but only those over the minimum are reviewed for possible compensation [SAMM ]. A shipment unit is defined as one of multiple shipments with the same document number but with a unique suffix code. Each shipment unit will have its own .

Another problem is caused by the use of multi-pack shipments. This is a packaging method whereby many different items are, for economic reasons, packed and shipped in a single container. The documentation on the outside of the crate or box can identify only the document used to track the container, while the numerous small items consolidated inside can be accounted for individually by the international partner.

Product quality deficiencies are defects or nonconforming conditions, which limit or prohibit the item from fulfilling its intended purpose. These include deficiencies in materiel, manufacturing, and workmanship, e.g., failure to put a gasket in a carburetor. A latent defect is defined as a deficiency in an article that affects the operability and is not normally detected by examination or routine test, but which was present at the time of manufacture.

An for an incorrect item can result when the shipping activity did not have the specific item in stock and shipped an authorized substitute, which carries a different stock number from the item ordered. Previously received status documentation shows whether a substitute was shipped. If the international partner does not desire a substitute, the appropriate advice code should be placed on the original requisition. There are times, however, when human error is involved and an incorrect item is shipped. If an item has not been identified as a suitable substitute for, or interchangeable with, the original item ordered, then an is appropriate.

A shelf life item is an item of supply possessing deteriorative or unstable characteristics to the degree that a storage time period is assigned to ensure that it performs satisfactorily in service. All shelf life items are categorized as one of the following two types:

  • TYPE I items are determined through an evaluation of technical test data and/or actual experience to have a non-extendable shelf-life. These items include fresh foods, vaccines, and drugs.
  • TYPE II items have an assigned shelf life that may be extended after completion of visual inspection/certified laboratory test, and/or restorative action. These products include petroleum, oil and lubricants, canned or packaged foods, and certain rubber-based products.

Under DoDM 4140.27, Volume 1, DoW Components issue or ship materiel on a first in, first out () basis and issue the oldest within the condition code specified, unless otherwise authorized. The volume provides the following exceptions for requisitions.

Under Volume 1, requisitions are issued in accordance with last in, first out () issue procedures. issue of non-extendable Type I shelf-life items is accomplished by issuing materiel with the latest date of expiration. Extendable Type II items are issued by the latest date of manufacture, date of cure, date of assembly, or date of pack (subsistence and Federal Supply Class 80 only) regardless of the number of extensions.

Under DoDM 4140.27, Volume 1, items with a shelf-life code () of 24 months or greater issued to satisfy either or Outside the () requirements are in supply condition code (SCC) A. They have a minimum of 12 months of shelf life remaining. Requisitioners have the option to waive that minimum by submitting exception requisitions. Items with an of less than 24 months are not subject to the minimum. They are issued from SCC A assets unless the customer specifies that other than SCC A materiel is acceptable or the designates a release from a specified material condition.

Shelf-life extensions for items/materiel in the custody of the international partner can be found by contacting the or international program offices having responsibility over the case. The office can access the DoW shelf-life extension system for applicable data and extension test results. Shelf-life extension policy for is contained in DoDM 4140.27, Volume 2, Shelf-Life Management Program.

may be submitted for materiel received in damaged condition if the damage is the result of improper preservation, packing, marking, loading, handling, or storage provided prior to title transfer. Damage that occurs after release to the carrier is a transportation discrepancy, not a supply discrepancy [SAMM , ].

A billing discrepancy involves materiel, which is received as ordered and with proper accompanying documentation, but the charge is incorrectly reflected on the quarterly billing statement provided by the Defense Finance and Accounting Service. These include duplicate or erroneous billings [SAMM , ]. The international partner can identify these problems by using the delivery listing provided as part of the quarterly billing statement.

When a discrepancy occurs in-transit, Organizations () must submit a DD Form 361: Transportation Discrepancy Report () for ()-routed and grant aid deliveries. The purchaser cannot submit a . procedures are found in the Defense Transportation Regulation (), 4500.9-R Part II, Chapter 210 [SAMM ] []. A documents lost shipments and establishes an official record for future claims against a carrier for loss or damage. Limited liability prevents the purchaser from receiving full value from a carrier, but if the purchaser obtains commercial insurance for its purchases, the official record may help the purchaser when submitting insurance claims. Whether shipments move via under collect or third-party billing terms to freight forwarders or are shipped prepaid to freight forwarders, the most that the purchaser might collect for loss or damage is the limited liability applicable to the commercial ocean, air, or inland carrier [SAMM ].

policy allows for reimbursement of transportation for discrepant materiel approved under an . The policy covers transportation reimbursement for the following:

  • items furnished by Defense Working Capital Funds () activities
  • items furnished by non- activities
  • Packing, crating, and handling relating to materiel
  • Local disposal relating to materiel
  • Transporting repaired items to the international partner

Under Policy Memo 03-15, Transportation Reimbursement Policy, the agency approving the reimbursement confirms that the policy's reimbursement prerequisites are met.

Try the tool: Discrepancy report or claim?

References

SAMM

Public authorities

  • DTR 4500.9-R: Defense Transportation Regulation, DTR 4500.9-R
  • DoDM 4140.27, Volume 2: DoD Manual 4140.27, Volume 2, DoD Shelf-Life Management Program: Materiel Quality Control Storage Standards
  • DoDM 4140.27, Volume 1: DoD Manual 4140.27, Volume 1, DoD Shelf-Life Management Program: Program Administration

Facts referenced

Related