Guide
What is a capabilities-based analysis in security cooperation?
A capabilities-based analysis is the planning method that defines the role a partner should play, measures the gap between the capabilities that role needs and those the partner has, weighs the risk of leaving the gap open, and works through alternative ways to close it.
What is a capabilities-based analysis in security cooperation?
A capabilities-based analysis defines the role a partner should play and measures the gap between the capabilities that role needs and those the partner has. It then weighs the risk of leaving the gap open and works through alternative ways to close it.
Capabilities-Based Analysis (CBA) is a modification of the doctrine used within the Department of War (DoW), but significantly streamlined and re-focused on () with foreign security forces. It is not the only way planners analyze problems and recommend solutions.
Pre-Letter of Request () work begins in one of three ways. A partner asks for U.S. Government support to address a capability gap or an operational requirement; a partner identifies a source of anticipated funding for procurement and asks for U.S. Government help in finding an effective use of those funds; or a U.S. Military Group () submits a Pre- Assessment Request [SAMM ].
Pre- activities end when the U.S. Government receives an , and the assessment then begins. In general, an official should not be submitted before the partner can name the specific defense articles or services it wants to acquire [SAMM ].
An analysis of a partner’s services can call for expertise the does not have. The first stop is the Senior Defense Official/Defense Attaché (/) and the military attachés in the , who understand the partner nation’s military and security forces. The can also reach out to the and its components to bring in experts to help with analysis.
The can also reach out to interagency partners with the needed subject-matter expertise. Determining strengths and weaknesses calls for a more finely tuned analysis, and a capability gap rooted in resource management or human resource management can call for specialists in those fields.
Problem analysis seeks to understand the situation in greater detail. It starts with clearly defining the “desired role” and determining what tasks are needed to achieve that role. During problem analysis, the defines the multiple roles that the partner is to play to reach the desired end state. This includes defining the primary role. A primary role is the description of a partner organization or unit and the desired actions that directly impact the threat or U.S. ability to directly impact the threat. In addition, the defines the supporting role, or roles, and governance/oversight roles. A support role describes the partner organization or unit and the actions they will take to support the partner organization’s performance of the primary role. For example, a unit can conduct intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance or rotary wing lift support to enable the partner organization or unit to conduct interdiction operations.
The analysis should also consider the governance/oversight role. The governance/oversight role describes those partner activities at the institutional level essential to enabling the partner to absorb, employ, and sustain the capability across its life cycle. These can include such functions as the development of legal frameworks and staff organizations and the execution of enduring policies and procedures to do the following: conduct strategic planning, manage resources, acquire equipment, manage personnel, develop operational concepts, and conduct life-cycle sustainment. For example, to fulfill a primary role of conducting maritime security operations with a new class of patrol boat, a partner may need to establish new legal frameworks to allow for effective cooperation with its Coast Guard, design new organizations to effectively conduct the operations, develop new joint operational concepts with its Coast Guard, or create new logistics and maintenance systems to sustain a new system operating in a new environment.
A needs assessment is an evaluative study that answers questions about partner nation conditions that an initiative is intended to address and the need for such an initiative [SAMM ]. Generally applicable to new or newly envisioned initiatives, needs assessments offer value by providing logical and disciplined methods for collecting useful information and making decisions about possible courses of action based on that information.
A needs assessment is an essential part of long-range plans. It lists the items the believes are necessary to maintain the country's defense [SAMM ].
While and DAO personnel can provide general assessments, the service component commands play a central role in assessing current capabilities. The services have technical expertise and resources to provide detailed assessments of partner nation (PN) capability. During the planning process, a significant effort should be made to understand the operational environment, to include PN forces, rather than an academic look focusing on open sources and intelligence information. During these assessments, service component commands should apply detailed standards evolved from their own operations (while recognizing varying tactics, techniques, and procedures) to conduct a detailed on-the-ground evaluation of each capability. The delta between required capabilities and those present in the PN forces are the “gaps.”
While assessments are often central to wise investment, the country-level planner keeps the scale of effort and priority of a particular country relative to the Campaign Plan () in mind. U.S. forces can apply U.S. standards (i.e., mirror-image) to PN operations, so planners and determine the extent of the desired assistance carefully to limit excessive resource expenditures. The needs, as determined in previous steps, drive the assessments. Operations by U.S. forces, assessments included, are expensive, and assessments can consume the same program funds as the eventual assistance.
must avoid creating false impressions of U.S. Government () willingness or ability to provide resources to the partner nation before official notification of approval arrives through channels [SAMM ]. If the program is small, the planner therefore takes care not to raise the PN’s expectations, as if the were promising to address all the gaps. Assessments can also wear on the patience of those being assessed. If the scale of the overall effort is modest, detailed, service-specific assessments are not always cost effective, and where the expertise exists in-country, the assessment can be left to the and attachés in-country.
Once these gaps have been identified, the planner assesses the risk. The military planner first assesses the risk posed to the U.S. strategy, i.e., the planned role for the PN if the capability gap persists. If it presents little risk, there is little point in providing the capability, so limited resources should be applied elsewhere. If this capability gap presents a major risk to the success of U.S. strategy for the proposed PN role, this indicates a higher priority for resourcing.
In addition to this operational risk, the planner also considers political risk: the fallout from not providing a capability and the risk from providing one, e.g., future atrocities by “U.S.-trained” personnel. The U.S. Ambassador to the PN weighs these concerns when looking at how the ’s country plan fits into the Department of State () overall strategy for U.S. relations with the PN.
At the country level, the military and diplomatic planning efforts come together and are meant to be synchronized.
Solutions analysis is the longest phase of planning. There are two primary methods for working through a capability to identify alternative solutions to fill the capability gaps: doctrine, organization, training, materiel, leadership, personnel, facilities, and policy () analysis and Joint Functions analysis.
The method works through a capability one area at a time. To apply this paradigm, planners work through each part of , asking what is needed within each domain. For example, to provide a reconnaissance capability, “What additional doctrine is needed? Do PN forces need to be reorganized? What training is needed? What equipment is needed?” Methodically working through guards against an overly narrow focus on equipment or training solutions and can identify lower-cost solutions before costlier ones [SAMM ].
In analyzing alternative solutions, the planner assesses each solution to determine whether it is affordable, feasible, and responsive. Thus, in practice, solutions analysis is often iterative with resourcing, as possible solutions succeed or fail to secure funding or manpower.
In the end, the PN consolidates and prioritizes these capabilities across all of its military services. The ability of PNs to conduct CBA and requirements integration varies from country to country. Where a PN does not present the with a coherent plan and capability requirements, the country-level planner ( or ) can integrate PN joint requirements and determine which best fulfills the strategic requirement.
Partners may ask the U.S. Government for support in determining which capability options could meet their requirements. For some partners, scoping requirements before the may be critical to helping them submit an actionable . The should work with the partner, the relevant and the geographic to define the partner's requirements in full [SAMM ].
Defining the partner's requirements may mean identifying the quantity, the desired configuration, the maintenance and sustainment package, the desired delivery date, delivery and transportation considerations, and the training and services the program needs. The should consider whether the requirements fit the partner's operational requirements, budget constraints and strategic objectives [SAMM ].
Where a partner specifically asks for before it submits an , the must follow the response guidance in Sections C5.3 and C5.4 [SAMM ]. When the and the refine these details during the pre- phase, they can help the partner develop actionable that close its capability gaps efficiently and effectively and stay in line with U.S. foreign policy goals [SAMM ].
References
SAMM
- SAMM AP8.S333.4.1.2: Needs Assessment.
- SAMM C2.1.3.6.2: Avoiding False Impressions.
- SAMM C15.2.6: Identification of Desired Capabilities.
- SAMM C5.1.2: Assisting Partners to Determine Operational Requirements.
- SAMM C5.1.1.1
- SAMM C2.3.2.2
- SAMM C5.1.3: Assisting Partners to Determine Requirements for Letter of Request.
Related
Security Cooperation
Activities by which the Department of War encourages and enables international partners to cooperate with the United States toward strategic objectives, spanning every interaction with foreign defense and security establishments and every security assistance program the Department administers.
Under chapter 16 of Title 10, their purposes are to develop allied and friendly security capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations, to give U.S. forces peacetime and contingency access, and to build relationships promoting specific U.S. security interests [10 U.S.C. 301(7)].
FMS Edge glossary, as of 10 October 2026
Glossary entry →Open the manual’s entry → (opens in new tab)
LOR: Letter of Request
SAMM Acronyms, as of 12 September 2026
Security Cooperation Organization (SCO)
A Department of Defense element that is part of the United States Diplomatic mission located in a foreign country to carry out security assistance and security cooperation management functions under the supervision and coordination authority of the senior defense official/defense attaché.
SAMM Glossary, as of 12 September 2026
Glossary entry →Open the manual’s entry → (opens in new tab)
Senior Defense Official (SDO) and Defense Attaché (DATT)
Principal DoD official in a U.S. embassy, as designated by the Secretary of Defense. The SDO or DATT is the Chief of Mission's principal military advisor on defense and national security issues, the senior diplomatically accredited DoD military officer assigned to a diplomatic mission, and the single point of contact for all DoD matters involving the embassy or DoD elements assigned to or working from the embassy. The SDO or DATT is considered the dual-hatted chief of both the Security Cooperation Organization and Defense Attaché Office in the embassy. This position was established by DoDD 5205.75, Department of Defense Operations at U.S. Embassies, December 21, 2007. The same document gives coordinating authority (see glossary definition) to the SDO or DATT for the purpose of ensuring that all DoD elements in a country are working in consonance with each other and under the guidance of the Chief of Mission. The SDO or DATT program replaces the now defunct U.S. Defense Representative model.
SAMM Glossary, as of 12 September 2026
Glossary entry →Open the manual’s entry → (opens in new tab)
Defense Attaché Office (DAO)
A DoD organization assigned to a U.S. diplomatic mission overseas for the purposes of overt gathering of military information, representing the U.S. DoD in the conduct of military liaison activities, and performing as a component of the U.S. country team. Several DAO's have been designated by the President as being responsible for security assistance functions in a host country.
SAMM Glossary, as of 12 September 2026
Glossary entry →Open the manual’s entry → (opens in new tab)
SCO: Security Cooperation Organization
SAMM Acronyms, as of 12 September 2026
Combatant Command (CCMD)
A unified or specified command with a broad continuing mission under a single commander established and so designated by the President, through the Secretary of Defense and with the advice and assistance of the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Also called CCMD.
SAMM Glossary, as of 12 September 2026
Glossary entry →Open the manual’s entry → (opens in new tab)
Country Team
The senior coordinating and supervising body of a U.S. diplomatic mission, headed by the chief of mission (normally the ambassador) and made up of the senior representative of each U.S. department or agency at the post. Its members meet regularly to coordinate U.S. Government political, economic and military activities and policies in the host country.
FMS Edge glossary, as of 10 October 2026
Glossary entry →Open the manual’s entry → (opens in new tab)
CCP: Combatant Command (CCMD) Campaign Plan
DOTMLPF-P: Doctrine, Organization, Training, Materiel, Leadership and Education, Personnel, Facilities and Policy
SAMM AP8.S333.T2
Implementing Agency (IA)
The military department or defense agency responsible for the execution of military assistance programs. With respect to FMS, the military department or defense agency assigned responsibility by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency to prepare an LOA and to implement an FMS case. The implementing agency is responsible for the overall management of the actions that will result in delivery of the materials or services set forth in the LOA that was accepted by a foreign country or international organization.
SAMM Glossary, as of 12 September 2026
Glossary entry →Open the manual’s entry → (opens in new tab)
Price and Availability (P&A)
Preliminary pricing and availability estimates for articles or services that an Implementing Agency (IA) prepares at the request of a foreign government or international organization for an international competition, or of a U.S. Government requesting authority for building partner capacity.
Price and Availability (P&A) responses are estimates of cost and availability, not valid for preparing a Letter of Offer and Acceptance (LOA), and furnishing them does not commit the U.S. Government to offer the articles or services for sale [SAMM C5.5.2, C5.5.1].
FMS Edge glossary, as of 10 October 2026
Glossary entry →Open the manual’s entry → (opens in new tab)
SAMM C5.1.1.1
“Pre-LOR work begins when a partner requests USG support to address a capability gap or operational requirement; a partner identifies a source of anticipated funding available for procurement and requests USG assistance with identifying an effective use of such funds; or a MILGP submits a Pre-LOR Assessment Request. Pre-LOR activities conclude upon USG receipt of an LOR, at which point …”
Security Assistance Management Manual, as of 5 October 2026
SAMM AP8.S333.4.1.2: Needs Assessment.
“The USG Requesting Authority (RA) (the geographic CCMD) will lead and facilitate participation of relevant subject matter experts to conduct a needs assessment on all proposed initiatives in order to answer questions about the need for an SC initiative and the Benefitting Partner conditions that the initiative is intended to address. The needs assessment will identify gaps between current and …”
Security Assistance Management Manual, as of 12 October 2026
SAMM C2.3.2.2
“A “needs assessment” is a critical part of long-range SC plans. The assessment lists items that the country team believes necessary to maintain the country’s defense.”
Security Assistance Management Manual, as of 11 September 2026
SAMM C2.1.3.6.2: Avoiding False Impressions.
“MILGPs must avoid creating false impressions of USG readiness to make available military materiel, technology, or information. Without specific existing authority, the only information that may be shared with a partner nation is that which has been cleared for public release. Therefore, planning and coordination with foreign governments concerning programs that might involve the eventual disclosure of military information may …”
Security Assistance Management Manual, as of 26 October 2026
SAMM C15.2.6: Identification of Desired Capabilities.
“The RA defines the Benefitting Partner’s military roles required to meet security objectives under existing and emerging security environments. This assessment should include a gap analysis of doctrine, organization, training, materiel, leadership, personnel, facilities, and policy (DOTMLPF-P) within the Benefitting Partner for each capability considered to prevent an overly narrow focus on equipment or training solutions. The assessment, captured in …”
Security Assistance Management Manual, as of 11 September 2026
SAMM C5.1.3: Assisting Partners to Determine Requirements for Letter of Request.
“Partners may request USG support in determining what capability options are available to meet their requirements. For some partners, scoping pre-LOR requirements may be critical to support the partner submitting an actionable LOR. The MILGP should, in collaboration with the partner, relevant IA, and geographic CCMD, collaborate to define the partner’s requirements comprehensively. This may include identifying the quantity, desired …”
Security Assistance Management Manual, as of 5 October 2026